Tuesday, April 16, 2019

Stargate Atlantis - "Common Ground" (TV Episode Review #20)


Oh no!  Kolya, the rogue Genii commander, has captured Lt. Col. John Sheppard!  And as Dr. Elizabeth Weir is holding a diplomatic conference on Atlantis with Radim, the new leader of the reformed Genii, Kolya channels in and offers a bargain to Dr. Weir: hand over Radim for Sheppard’s freedom.  If they don’t, Kolya will keep on torturing Sheppard with his “secret weapon.”  Will the Atlantis team locate Sheppard in time and set him free?

If it rings true that a story is only as good as its villain, then Kolya (played by Robert Davi) totally makes this episode.  Right now, he covets the position of the Genii head of state, which is why he’s trying to crack that deal with Weir; in other words, this guy is bargaining a coup. (Jeez, didn’t the Genii go through one of those, already?) The fact that he is willing to kill Sheppard slowly by Wraith is a perfect underlining of how dastardly evil he really is.  And you know what’s the worst part?  Kolya doesn’t seem to hesitate when he gives the orders.  Quite often, he coldly shrugs it off and acts like this is just the usual business.  That’s what makes him truly threatening and terrifying—the fact that he’s so indifferent about the brutal torture he is inflicting upon Sheppard.  He doesn’t care if a person dies, just as long as he finally gets the position he seeks.  Now, that is pure evil.

Did I just mention Sheppard’s sentence is death by Wraith?  Because it turns out, Kolya’s secret weapon is a Wraith.  And not just any Wraith—it’s actually Todd!  Yes, “Common Ground” marks the debut of the show’s arguably most prominent (and most popular, with the fandom) Wraith character.  However, this is not the Todd who we would come to know and love (as in, the antiheroic Wraith known for his dark sense of humor) when we meet him again during the Carter & Woolsey seasons.  In his first appearance, he has been imprisoned and starved by the Genii for quite some time.  So he’s hungry.  And angry.  As such, he basks in feeding on Sheppard when given the chance to.  After all, he’s acting like a human who had been starved for days only to be suddenly given an extra-large bucket of fried chicken.  He is mainly seeking his own ends, but is willing to cooperate with Sheppard when necessary.

Since Sheppard is inmates with his own torturer, he might as well get to know him.  The discussions that Sheppard has with Todd make for some nuance, allowing for a new perspective on the Wraith.  While this is not the first time the Wraith have been humanized (although Michael’s humanization at the end of Season 2 was more literal than figurative), Todd is given a platform to speak about his species’ biological nature and defend their primal instincts of feeding on humans.  He is also quick to remind him, “There is much about Wraith that you do not know, Sheppard.”  This is a hook that adds to the mystery and is properly built upon at the end of the episode in quite a satisfying way.

(On a side note, hats off to the makeup artist for making actor Joe Flanigan look like an old man when after Sheppard gets fed upon.  He not only looks old and wrinkly, but also weak and frail.  It is so convincing it is almost terrifying.)

In the meantime, the scenes at Atlantis between Dr. Weir, the Atlantis team, and Radim are where the plot is at its most standard, to say the least.  This formula of debating on how to rescue Lt. Col. Sheppard has every reason to come off as repetitive, but it works thanks to not only how spaced out their scenes are throughout the episode, but also to how the perspectives of Weir, Radim, and the Atlantis team differentiate and interact with one another.  The climax is more action-oriented, a straightforward action sequence that culminates with a resolution that may come off as a deus ex machina if it was not properly foreshadowed and built up just by Todd’s reminder earlier on.  Furthermore, this resolution also introduces a new element of the mythology about the Wraith that future episodes would also address and build upon.

You know what?  This was actually a really good episode.  It was engaging, suspenseful, and actually quite nuanced, too.  It presented another worthy effort to characterize and humanize the Wraith, and it did so successfully.  Plus, Kolya once again proves himself as one of the most evil and threatening characters in Stargate Atlantis.

No comments:

Post a Comment

A Long, Long Time (A Captain America Fanfic)

Having returned all the other Infinity Stones to their rightful places, Steve Rogers has one stone left: the Soul Stone. On Vormir, he tak...